






























































































































Amara Cay Resort
What to expect
Pros
- 🎣Excellent fishing experience with a knowledgeable fishing guru
- 🍹Welcoming tiki bar with great drinks and atmosphere
- 🌺Friendly and attentive staff at every department
- 🏊♂️Beautiful pool area with ocean views
- 🎶Live music entertainment adding to the overall ambiance
- 🚤Enjoyable watertaxi experience with a skilled captain and crew
- 🙏Helpful and accommodating service for special occasions
- 🍴Excellent dining options with attentive servers
- 🏝️Lovely beach and pool areas for relaxation and fun
- 🌴Beautiful grounds and tropical vibe for a true vacation feel
Cons
- 📱Issues with room maintenance and slow response to fix amenities
- ❄️Cold pool temperatures impacting the enjoyment of the pool area
- 💡Insufficient lighting in rooms affecting visibility
- 🔇TVs with volume control issues and poor functionality
- 🚪Phone communication problems inside the rooms
- 💰High resort fees without corresponding value or service
- 🧼Lack of toiletries and amenities in the rooms
- 🔊Inadequate soundproofing or noise issues in room
- 🍔Limited or overpriced dining options at the resort
- 🏨Issues with room quality and maintenance affecting comfort
What this place has to offer
Located in Upper Matecumbe Key, Amara Cay Resort is a perfect starting point from which to explore Islamorada (FL). Featuring a satisfying list of amenities, guests will find their stay at the property a comfortable one. Service-minded staff will welcome and guide you at Amara Cay Resort. Each guestroom is elegantly furnished and equipped with handy amenities. Take a break from a long day and make use of the fitness center. Discover all Islamorada (FL) has to offer by making Amara Cay Resort your base.
Where you'll be sleeping






Partial Ocean View King
1 king bed






Standard Two Queen
2 queen beds






Partial Ocean View 2 Queen
2 queen beds




Accessible Standard King
1 king bed





Oceanfront King Accessible
1 king bed




KING OCEANFRONT
1 king bed




Suite with Sea View
2 double beds & 1 sofa bed




Standard King Room
1 king bed







Courtyard View King Room
1 king bed




Oceanfront Suite with Two Queen Beds
2 double beds & 1 sofa bed
What other guests say about this hotel
Is this hotel improving or worsening?
We've analyzed the reviews to find out if this hotel is improving or worsening. On average, this hotel is worsening 0.00% over the period.
Who should stay here
We've analyzed the reviews to find out what different types of travelers think about this hotel.
When to stay here
We've analyzed the reviews to find out what months are best to stay here.